Evidence

Claim checks

paperiswrong works best when it checks one concrete claim at a time: a table value, metric, sentence, or short quoted span. This page shows the exact claim citations attached to current reproduction verdicts.

Live counts

  • Total claims
    0
  • Verified
    0
  • Partial
    0
  • Did not reproduce
    0
  • Not checkable
    0
  • Ambiguous
    0

What the labels mean

Verified is reserved for exact-protocol results with a persisted validation receipt. The receipt binds the exact job, paper version, protocol, measurement, outcome, cited paper locator, and PDF bytes checked by the validator.

Partially supported requires the same citation receipt, but the result was partial or used a declared proxy such as a micro-slice, community checkpoint, or nearby evaluation setup.

Did not reproduce requires an exact protocol and the same receipt. It describes only the cited claim and measured setup, not the entire paper.

Not checkable means the evidence is insufficient to make a claim-level conclusion: for example, the protocol targeted another benchmark, the model is gated, or a legacy job has no current validation receipt.

Checked claims

No receipt-backed claim checks are public yet. Stored legacy or unchecked citations remain hidden until the validator can bind the paper span, measurement, protocol, and outcome. The JSON mirror lives at /api/v1/claims.

Scope

A claim check is smaller than a paper verdict. It says whether a specific cited value or span matched the reproduction job under the stated protocol, not whether the whole paper is good or bad.